多边形综合指标法在上海市设施菜田农药减量技术评估中的应用  

Application of polygon synthesis for pesticide reduction evaluation in protected horticultural vegetable fields in Shanghai

作　　者：万年峰[1] 蒋杰贤[1] 季香云[1] 

机构地区：[1]上海市农业科学院生态环境保护研究所,上海市设施园艺技术重点实验室,上海201106

出　　处：《环境科学学报》2008年第3期582-588,共7页Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae

基　　金：上海市科技兴农重点攻关项目(农科攻字2005第6-1-2号);国家“十五”重点科技攻关项目(No.2001BA503B05);中意环保合作项目~~

摘　　要：将综合效益分为经济效益、社会效益、生态效益3个元素,综合代价分为经济代价、社会代价、生态代价3个元素,将参加综合代价评价的指标优化矩阵与参加综合效益评价的指标优化矩阵的比称为综合代价效益比矩阵;运用多边形指标法的基本原理和方法,构建了综合代价效益比RCC/CP模型,将其应用于上海市设施菜田农药减量技术评估体系中,并根据不同控害方案产生的综合代价效益比值将控害功能分为优良、较好、一般、较差和很差5个等级.结果表明,"防虫网室2.2m"(RCC/CP=0.4363)、"防虫网室2.7m"(RCC/CP=0.4622)、"防虫网室3.2m"(RCC/CP=0.4786)均达到"较好"等级,"薄膜遮阳防虫网室2.7m"(RCC/CP=0.5153)的控害功能达到"一般"等级,对照"露地常规防治区"(RCC/CP=1.1001)的控害功能为"很差"等级,其中,"防虫网室2.2m"是本试验中最优的农药减量控害措施.In this paper we divide Comprehensive Profit （CP） into 3 elements-economic, social and ecological profit-and split up Comprehensive Cost （CC） into 3 groups-economic, social and ecological cost. Based on the polygon synthesis index method we construct a RCC/CP model, i.e. the matrix of Ratio of Comprehensive Cost to Comprehensive Profit （RCC/CP） , where the RCC/CP index matrix WCC/CP is defined as the index optimization matrix of CC divided by the index optimization matrix of CP. The RCC/CP model was applied to evaluate pesticide reduction techniques in protected horticultural vegetable fields in Shanghai. According to the value of RCC/CP of different pest-control methods, we assigned insect pest-control functions into 5 levels： excellent, better, general, bad, and worst. The evaluation results show that the pest-control functions of treatments ＂2.2 m high gray insect-proof net rooms ＂ （RCC/CP = 0. 4363 ） , ＂2.7 m high gray insect-proof net rooms＂ （ RCC/CP = 0. 4622 ） and ＂3.2 m high gray insect-proof net rooms＂ （ RCC/CP = 0. 4786） were all excellent, while ＂white insect-proof thin film rooms＂ （RCC/CP = 0.5153） was general, ＂common control and prevention areas without any covering nets or thin films＂ （RCC/CP = 1. 1001 ） were worse; so use of ＂2.2 m high gray insect-proof net rooms＂ was our best insect pest-control technique.

关 键 词：综合代价效益比 农药减量 设施菜田 多边形综合指标法 评估 

分 类 号：X32[环境科学与工程—环境工程]