评《蒋祈〈陶记〉著作时代考辨》——与刘新园先生商榷  

A REVIEW OF THE THESIS"INQUIRY INTO THE DATE OF WRITING OF THE TAO JI BY JIANG QI":DISCUSSION WITH MR.LIU XINYUAN

作　　者：马文宽[1] 

机构地区：[1]中国社会科学院考古研究所,北京100710

出　　处：《考古学报》2008年第3期395-414,共20页Acta Archaeologica Sinica

摘　　要：《陶记》是中国第一部有关陶瓷生产技术、管理及其行销等方面的论著，对其进行深入的理解和断代有益于中国陶瓷史、科技史的研究，故我国老一辈陶瓷研究学者傅振伦、陈万里、冯先铭等先生都对《陶记》给以关注，傅振伦先生在耋耄之年（1979年）还对《陶记》进行了译注。约与《陶记》同时期，伊朗人阿布尔·卡西姆于1301年著有《阿布尔·卡西姆有关陶瓷的论著》。两文均受到国内外陶瓷学者的重视。The book Tao di 《陶记》（Records on Ceramics） is the first work on the making technology, manufacture management and product marketing of ceramics in China and has long drawn attention from scholars both at home and abroad. Traditionally the date of its writing is believed to be in the Yuan period. Nevertheless, in the early 1980s, Mr. Liu Xinyuan put forward in his thesis that the book was written in the Southern Song period. The present paper makes a review on Liu＇s use of data and research method. Although Liu＇s points of view contain some reasonable elements,

关 键 词：陶记 著作时代 刘新 考辨 陶瓷史 生产技术 傅振伦 科技史 

分 类 号：K876.3[历史地理—考古学及博物馆学]