科技期刊编辑初审退稿理由分析及退稿程序公平性的构建  

Analysis of the reasons for contribution rejection of sci-tech periodicals'initial examination of editors and the construction of the fairness of contribution rejection procedure

作　　者：蔡骏翔[1] 罗萍[1] 

机构地区：[1]重庆医科大学杂志编辑部,重庆400016

出　　处：《编辑学报》2010年第1期31-32,共2页Acta Editologica

摘　　要：科技期刊编辑部因收稿量大,在初审时会筛选出相当数量的稿件作退稿处理。退稿原因大致可分为稿件内容不符合期刊需要,存在科学性错误,存在知识产权问题或涉及泄密问题,存在政治、民族、宗教信仰方面的问题等几大类。根据退稿理由的不同,应构建较为公平的初审退稿程序。Owing to the large number of received papers of sci-tech periodicals,a considerable number of contributions will be screened out as contribution rejection after the initial examination.The reasons for rejected papers can be roughly divided into such categories as contributing papers＇ non-conformity to the requirement of the journal,academic errors,the problems of intellectual property rights or divulgence,the problems involving politics,races and religious faith etc.To these different reasons,the authors put forward a relatively fair procedure of contribution rejection.

关 键 词：科技期刊 稿件初审 退稿程序 公平性 

分 类 号：G237.5[文化科学] G232