马克思交换价值理论不能与边际效用论综合为一个新理论——析樊纲的新交换价值理论  

Marx's Theory of Exchange Value and the Theory of Marginal Utility Can Not be Combined as a New Theory——An Analysis of Fan Gang's New Exchange-Value Theory

作　　者：巫文强[1] 

机构地区：[1]广西壮族自治区社会科学界联合会编辑部,广西南宁530022

出　　处：《改革与战略》2010年第4期1-5,共5页Reformation & Strategy

摘　　要：樊纲在其专著《现代三大经济理论体系的比较与综合》中的新交换价值理论错误地认为,商品之间的使用价值关系在马克思简单价值形式(物物交换形式)中的表现,与效用在边际效用均衡规律中的表现有共同之处,使用价值与效用是相同的。樊纲分别篡改了马克思价值理论和边际效用学派的消费者边际效用均衡理论,然后又把它们机械地组合起来,所形成的新交换价值理论不是对马克思价值论和边际效用论的有机综合,是一个没有理论依据和不能自圆其说的理论。Fan Gang, in his monograph ＂Comparison and Synthesis of Three Major Approaches in Economics＂, mistakenly considers that the performance of use value which embodied in Marx＇s simple form of value（barter form） and the performance of utility in the law of marginal utility equilibrium have something in common. That is to say, the use value and utility are the same. Fan Gang falsifies Marx＇s Value Theory and the Marginal Utility School＇s consumer marginal utility equilibrium theory, and then mechanically combined them together to form a new exchange-value theory, which is not an integration of Marx＇s theory of value and marginal utility theory, but a theory which is not internally consistent.

关 键 词：新交换价值理论 马克思价值理论 使用价值 边际效用 

分 类 号：F014.3[经济管理—政治经济学]