江有诰《诗经韵读》和王念孙《古韵谱》用韵比较  

The Rhyme Analysis on the Books of "Rhyme Analysis of the Book of Songs" and "Rhyme Spectrum"

作　　者：曹强[1] 

机构地区：[1]渭南师范学院中文系,陕西渭南714000

出　　处：《安康学院学报》2010年第6期41-47,共7页Journal of Ankang University

基　　金：陕西省教育厅人文社科项目(09JK073);渭南师范学院科研计划项目(10KYZ045)

摘　　要：江有诰《诗经韵读》与王念孙《古韵谱》的用韵差异主要表现在五个方面:对句末韵字的入韵方式理解不同;对某些句中字是否入韵理解不同;对句末韵字和句中字是否同时押韵理解不同;对某些句子或篇章是否有韵理解不同;对某些篇章韵例理解相同,但对入韵字理解不同。通过比较发现,总体而论,江氏和王氏在研究《诗经》用韵上各有得失,江氏之得远远多于王氏。相较而言,江氏对韵和非韵的辨别,比王氏高明;江氏比王氏更注重同篇各章在韵式上的整齐性;江氏在分析句中字是否入韵时,较王氏谨慎;江氏对某些句子或篇章是否入韵的处理,较王氏有道理。Jiang Yougao＇s the Rhyme Analysis of the Book of Songs and WangNiansun＇s Rhyme Spectrum the main differences between rhyme performance in five areas：the end of the sentence into words rhyme understanding of different ways;for certain whether the word into the rhyme sentence different understanding;on the end of the sentence and the sentence of a rhyme for rhyme characters are also different understanding;on certain sentences or understand the different chapters have rhyme;rhyme cases of some chapters to understand the same,but different understanding of the word into the rhyme.By comparison,overall speaking,the study of Jiang and Wang,The Book of Songs,each with a rhyme on the gains and losses,and far more than the Wang of Jiang.In comparison,of Jiang and non-rhyme for rhyme identification,sophisticated than Wang;Wang more attention than the chapter with the chapter on the uniformity of rhyme style;of Jiang in the analysis of whether the word into the rhyme when the sentence compared with cautious Wang;of Jiang whether certain sentences or chapters into the rhyme of the treatment,compared with Wang sense.

关 键 词：江有诰 王念孙 《诗经韵读》 《古韵谱》 《诗经》韵例 

分 类 号：H11[语言文字—汉语]