WTO与NAFTA争端解决机制管辖权冲突研究  

Research on the Jurisdictional Conflict between WTO and NAFTA Dispute Settlement Mechanisms

作　　者：何志鹏[1] 隽薪[1] 

机构地区：[1]吉林大学法学院,吉林长春130012

出　　处：《世界贸易组织动态与研究（上海对外贸易学院学报）》2011年第2期57-64,共8页Journal of Shanghai University of International Business and Economics

基　　金：何志鹏教授主持的教育部人文社会科学项目"和谐世界语国际法治"(07JA820006)的阶段性成果

摘　　要：由于管辖范围存在重叠而又缺少协调规则,WTO与区域贸易协定间普遍存在着发生管辖权冲突的可能。实践中案例已有多起,本文仅以NAFTA为例分析了管辖权冲突产生的原因及后果,考察了WTO在实践中的做法及传统解决冲突原则能发挥作用的空间,得出冲突无法避免又实难解决的结论,并认为在此情况下减轻冲突不良后果的途径或许是一种更为明智的选择,指出NAFTA在实践中的做法将为其他区域贸易协定处理与WTO的关系提供有益的借鉴。Jurisdictional conflict may widely occur between WTO and RTAs since there is some overlap in jurisdiction and lack of coordination rules, There have been several cases in practice, this paper takes NAFTA for example analysing the causes and consequences of the jurisdictional conflict, examines the practice of WTO and the function of the traditional conflict resolution. The conclusion is that the jurisdictional conflict is unavoidable and insoluble, in this case, alleviating the negative consequences of conflict is perhaps an even more sensible choice. Finally, it indicates that NAFTA approach in practice would provide a useful reference to dealing with the relationship between WTO and other RTAs.

关 键 词：WTO NAFTA 争端解决机制 管辖权冲突 

分 类 号：F744[经济管理—国际贸易]