“天禄琳琅”版本鉴定错误及其原因探析  

The Edition Authentication Errors of Tianlu Linlangand its Reasons for the Mistakes

作　　者：刘蔷[1] 

机构地区：[1]清华大学图书馆,北京100084

出　　处：《图书馆杂志》2011年第9期73-86,57,共15页Library Journal

基　　金：国家社会科学基金课题"海内外现存清宫天禄琳琅书的调查与研究"(项目编号:09BTQ016)成果之一

摘　　要："天禄琳琅"藏书是清代著名的宫廷善本特藏。本文在全面调查海内外存世天禄书的基础上,以《天禄琳琅书目》与存世书相互对勘,结合文献、他书,考证辨别,首次统计出《天禄琳琅书目》前后编中版本鉴定错误的总体情况,得出整部《天禄琳琅书目后编》版本误判比例高达三分之一,而宋元版部分更是几近三分之二的结论。对这些鉴定错误加以归纳分析,并从主观、客观两个方面探讨其致误原因。Tianlulinlang is known as the rare imperial special collections in the royal court of Qing Dynasty. The summing up and analyzing of the authentication errors in the catalogue is based on a comparative edition evaluation of the extant books collected by public and private institutes home and abroad. After a statistical study, it is my conclusion that the authentication errors amount to one - third of the Tianlu Linlang Shumu Houbian titles, and in the section of Song and Yuan editions they are nearly two -thirds. Finally, I explain the reasons for the mistakes from both subjective and objective factors.

关 键 词：天禄琳琅 皇家藏书 版本鉴定 

分 类 号：G256.2[文化科学—图书馆学]