关于《登科记考》补正的几个问题——兼评王洪军教授新著《登科记考再补正》  

On Several Correction Issues about Historical Records of Successful Imperial Examinations Candidates——A Comment on Prof.Wang Hongjun's Re-supplement Correction of Historical Records of Successful Imperial Examinations Candidates

作　　者：许友根[1] 

机构地区：[1]盐城师范学院教育科学研究所,江苏盐城224002

出　　处：《晋阳学刊》2012年第6期101-105,共5页Academic Journal of Jinyang

摘　　要：《登科记考再补正》主要存在重复录载前人已经使用的史料而没有进行任何考证、将史料中凡有"进士"字样的人全部录载为"及第进士"、依据未经考证的方志与宗谱等史料录载登科人名以及由于不清楚武举考试的基本史实而产生的误载等方面的问题。不仅影响到该书作为史料工具书的科学性和可信度,更事关后续研究成果的学术价值,值得学界引起足够重视。Some problems are existent in Re-supplement and Correction of Historical Records of Successful Imperial Examinations Candidates, e.g. simply repeating the historical data used by predecessors without any verification, recording all the persons who were described as ＇Jin Shi＇ in historical data as ＇Ji Di Jin Shi＇, recording according to unverified local histories or family trees and some mistake caused by being unfamiliar with Wuju examination. These problems affect not only the scientificalness and reliability of this book as a historical reference, but also the value of following reseraches. It is worthy for the academia to pay attention to it.

关 键 词：《登科记考》 《登科记考补正》 《登科记考再补正》 

分 类 号：K207[历史地理—历史学]