论信访代议替代的不可行性  

The Impossibility of the Replacement of Petition with Representative

作　　者：张红霞[1] 

机构地区：[1]川北医学院思政部,四川南充637000

出　　处：《德州学院学报》2013年第5期37-40,51,共5页Journal of Dezhou University

摘　　要：面对司法、行政手段都无法解决信访问题的社会现实,信访"弱化论"在借鉴西方民意表达机制经验的基础上提出把信访并入人大的设想,即代议替代设想。虽然我国的人民代表大会在权力分配上类似于西方的议会,然而在权力制约、选举方式、决策程序等方面,二者存在明显的不同,忽视我国人大与西方议会的区别,单纯的借鉴国外的处理经验不利于信访问题的解决。Facing the social reality that judicial and administrative means were unable to solve the problem of letters and visits, Advocates of weakening the complaint scholar vision letters into people＇s Congress on the basis of the experience of expression mechanism in Western public opinion, Representative alternative vision. Although the people＇s Congress of China is similar to the Western Congress in power distribution, there is a marked difference in the powers by the power or by the rights, a combination of indirect elections and direct elections or a pure directly elected, solving political issues or the specific problems and decision --making process. It is bad to solve the problem that ignoring the differences between China＇s national people＇s Congress and Western Parliament turn entirely to foreign experience for reference to letters and visits.

关 键 词：信访制度 人大监督 代议替代 人民代表大会 

分 类 号：D632.8[政治法律—政治学]