乱点鸳鸯谱——论《现代学林点将录》之章太炎篇  

Unreasonable Match:Discussion on the Review of Zhang Taiyan in A Ranking of Modern Scholars

作　　者：丁守伟[1] 

机构地区：[1]华中师范大学中国近代史研究所,湖北武汉430079

出　　处：《学术界》2014年第1期106-111,309,共6页Academics

摘　　要：胡文辉在其《现代学林点将录》中,把章太炎列为"旧头领一员",将之摒于现代学林正榜之外,认为与康梁与罗王相比,章黄学派在政治上激进,在学术上保守,章黄学派对现代学林的影响并不深刻。笔者认为,胡先生对章太炎的点评,纯属乱点鸳鸯谱,并从文中对章太炎所指摘的排满革命、门户之见、排斥甲骨文及对现代学林的影响等方面提出自己的一得之见,与胡先生商榷。Hu Wenhui in A Ranking of Modern Scholars considered that the Zhang- Huang School was radical in politics but conservative in academic,and had no deep impact on modern academic compared with Kang Youwei,Liang Qichao,Luo Zhenyu and Wang Guowei.Therefore,he regarded Zhang Taiyan as one of the old leaders and didn't list his name in the first class of modern scholars.We think that Hu's review on Zhang Taiyan was unreasonable and unreliable.Meanwhile we put forward personal opinions to discuss with Mr.Hu on Zhang Taiyan from the following aspects: the anti-qing revolution,parochial prejudice,excluding oracle and the impact on modern academic.

关 键 词：现代学林点将录 章太炎 乱点鸳鸯谱 

分 类 号：K825.1[历史地理—历史学]