关于萧绎《山水松石格》与王维《山水诀》再探讨  

Xiaoyi's Shan Shui Song Shi Ge and Wangwei's Shan Shui Jue Are Pseudographs By One Author

作　　者：易善炳[1] 徐兆轩 

机构地区：[1]陕西师范大学美术学院,陕西西安710119

出　　处：《新疆艺术学院学报》2014年第1期62-65,共4页Journal of Xinjiang Arts University

摘　　要：萧绎《山水松石格》与王维《山水诀》被画学界视为伪作,并被认为作伪的时间也不尽同。笔者认为这两篇画论系同一人所作伪。原因在于两篇行文开端格调基本一致,描写内容如出一辙。分别与同期画论作比较,文法迥异,但两者相比较,确有不谋而合之处,甚至感觉两者的篇名可以互换。这两篇画论可能系北宋初期之前的山水画家所作。Xiaoyi＇s Shan Shui Song Shi Ge and Wangwei＇s Shan Shui Jue are pseudographs in the academia, and they have different written times .My view is that they are written by one author. The reason is that they have the same writing style on the begining. Description of the content is all the same rule. Compared to the painting theories of the same time, they have different grammars. When comparing the two, there are many similarities. The two names Xiaoyi＇s Shan Shui Song Shi Ge and Wangwei＇s Shan Shui Jue are used interchangeably. They are written before the early Northern Son~ Dynasty.

关 键 词：萧绎 王维 《山水松石格》 《山水诀》 伪作 

分 类 号：J209.2[艺术—美术]