《明史断略》作者考辨——兼论《明事断略》与《明史断略》的关系  

Textual Research on the Author of MINGSHIDUANLUE:Together with the Relationship between DuanLue of Events in Ming Dynasty and MINGSHIDUANLUE

作　　者：杨绪敏[1] 姜明会 

机构地区：[1]江苏师范大学历史文化学院,江苏徐州221116

出　　处：《史学史研究》2014年第3期34-39,59,共7页Journal of Historiography

基　　金：国家社科基金项目"明末清初私家修史研究"(项目编号:11BZS001)阶段性成果

摘　　要：现存单卷本《明史断略》,作者署名钱谦益。另有同名四卷本,署名彭而述。两书内容基本相同。有人认为是彭而述对钱著进行了评点与续写,两书相同的部分是彭氏抄袭钱著的。实际上,彭而述撰写《明史断略》是毋庸置疑的。而题名钱谦益所作《明史断略》则从史观、所载史事、人物事迹上与钱氏及其所载大相径庭,显然非出自钱氏之手。署名钱氏单卷本《明史断略》是彭氏《明史断略》抄本的残本。而《明事断略》则是在抄写署名钱氏本的基础上,以自己对史事、人物的认识改窜原文而成。The author＇s name of the existing single volume of MINGSHIDUANLUE was Qian Qianyi. There was another four-volume book with the same name, which was written by Peng Ershu. These two books are basically the same. Some people believe that Peng just made some contents and sequel on Qian＇s. And the same part of two books plagiarizes Qian＇s books. In fact, MINGSHIDUANLUE was absolutely written by Peng. However, from historical views, events and characters, it was quite different from Qian＇s usual writing styles. It was obviously not from his hand. Qian＇s single volume book was Peng＇s aberrant copy of manuscript. DuanLue of Events in Ming Dynasty was written on the basis of Qian＇s book and by altering the latter, with the author＇s own understanding about events and characters.

关 键 词：钱谦益 《明史断略》 《明事断略》 作者 考辨 

分 类 号：K092[历史地理—历史学]