对冯锐复原地动仪若干质疑的述评  

Queries About Feng Rui's Restoration of Zhang Heng's Seismograph

作　　者：张正严[1,2] 关增建[2] 

机构地区：[1]西南大学科学教育研究中心,重庆400715 [2]上海交通大学科学史与科学文化研究院,上海200240

出　　处：《自然辩证法通讯》2015年第1期149-154,共6页Journal of Dialectics of Nature

基　　金：西南大学中央高校基本科研业务费专项资金资助(项目编号:XDJK2013C078);重庆市人文社会科学重点研究基地重点项目(项目编号:14SKB036)

摘　　要：冯锐及其课题组对张衡地动仪的复原设计目前在国内外产生了一定的影响。本文在梳理冯锐复原张衡地动仪的主要创见的基础上,就李志超、王鹏飞、李强等对冯锐地动仪的质疑做了陈述和评论,并在此基础上,就冯锐对张衡地动仪的复原设计也提出了一些疑问:1.冯锐的设计没有体现出盖子的用处,其对仪器维修和调整的设计不尽合理;2.冯锐复原设计的关键之处与原始文献记载不能密合。The restoration design of Zhang Heng＇s seismograph by Feng Rui and his research team has exerted certain impacts home and abroad. Based on Feng＇s original ideas in the restoration of Zhang Heng＇s seismograph, this paper states and comments on the queries about Feng＇s ideas carried out by Li Zhichao, Wang Pengfei, Li Qiang etc. Then the author also raises some queries about the restoration design of Feng Rui. First, the usage of the tops is not reflected in Feng＇s design, and the design for repair and adjustment is not so reasonable. Second, the key part of Feng＇s design does not completely accord with the records in the original literature.

关 键 词：地动仪 冯锐 质疑 述评 

分 类 号：N0[自然科学总论—科学技术哲学]