《明史纪事本末·东林党议》与《东林始末》关系考  

The Relations Dynasty about“Dong Lin Party Struggles”Implied in“Historyofthe Ming Dynasty Chronicle Insand Outs”and“Dong Lin Chronicle Ins and Outs”

作　　者：阚琉声 

机构地区：[1]南开大学历史学院,天津300071

出　　处：《齐鲁学刊》2015年第1期56-58,共3页Qilu Journal

摘　　要：谷应泰《明史纪事本末》卷六六《东林党议》部分与蒋平阶《东林始末》一书几乎雷同,学界多持谷应泰抄袭蒋氏之说。事实并非如此,蒋平阶应是谷应泰编纂《明史纪事本末》的作者群之一,在遵循《明史纪事本末》全书布局的情况下具体负责撰写"东林党议"这一部分的初稿。后来,蒋氏这一史稿被独立析出印行,改题目为《东林始末》,却未及进行必要的补充。于是,造成了蒋平阶《东林始末》与《明史纪事本末·东林党议》并行流传而内容又几乎雷同这一状况。The＂Dong Lin Party Struggles＂Implied in ＂History of the Ming Dynasty Chronicle Ins And Outs＂which was GuYingtai with＂Dong Lin Chronicle Ins And Outs＂which was completed by Jiang Pingjie were almost identical.Many academics believe thatGuYingtaiPlagiarized the work of Jiang Pingjie.That is not the fact.Jiang Pingjie participated in the compilation of the＂History of the Ming Dynasty Chronicle Ins And Outs＂.Jiang Pingjie compiled the Draft of＂Dong Lin Party Struggles＂in the case of the layout of GuYingtai＇s work.Later,the Draft of＂Dong Lin Party Struggles＂published separately and renamed＂Dong Lin Chronicle Ins And Outs＂in the case of intact.Thus,it formed the situation that＂Dong Lin Party Struggles＂Implied in＂History of the Ming Dynasty Chronicle Ins and Outs＂and ＂Dong Lin Chronicle Ins and Outs＂spreadparallel and had the Same content.

关 键 词：谷应泰 东林党议 蒋平阶 东林始末 

分 类 号：K204[历史地理—历史学]