典範與牽引——鄧小南《祖宗之法——北宋前期政治述略》讀後  

Paradigm and Traction: A Comment on Invoking Imperial Ancestors' Instructions in Early Northern Song Politics,by Deng Xiaonan

作　　者：刁培俊[1] 仝相卿[2] 

机构地区：[1]厦门大学历史学系 [2]河南大学中国古代史研究中心

出　　处：《中华文史论丛》2016年第4期153-179,共27页Journal of Chinese Literature and History

基　　金：中央高校基本科研業務費專項資金資助(編號:NKZXA1407);中國博士後第58批面上資助(編號:2015M582177)之中期成果

摘　　要：鄧小南所著《祖宗之法》一書,無論是問題意識之蘊涵及旨歸、論證過程的邏1清晰和雄辯有力、史料之豐贍、解讀之確當、結論之穩妥,在國内中國古代史研究領域,抑或在國際漢學研究領域,均深獲好評,堪稱典範之作。其問題意識建構,學術論證,引起學人追慕而效法。本文自論題形塑的準確性和前瞻性,論證方式和過程的學術理性,水中鹽味、史識深蘊等三個方面試作評論。在"閱讀者的困惑"部分,導因於"致君堯舜上"之改寫"致師孔孟上",則是一孔之見的"春秋責賢"。Invoking Imperial Ancestors' Instructions in Early Northern Song Politics written by Deng Xiaonan is highly praised both in the field of domestic research on the ancient history of China or in the field of international sinology. As a scholar, she displays the intense questionable consciousness and provides the clear and powerful arguments in the book. She also explains a large number of historical materials correctly and gets a sound conclusion as well. So the book is indeed an excellent model. More and more researchers follow professor Deng's way to cultivate the sense of questioning and the method of launching academic arguments. This paper focuses on the accuracy and prospect of the topic for the thesis,rational ways to interpret historical data and the cultivation of the deep understanding on history,attempts to make a comment on professor Deng's book and puts forward some own opinions in the 'reader's confusion'part.

关 键 词：《祖宗之法》 学术典范 学术牵引力 

分 类 号：K244[历史地理—历史学]