物权合同的发现:从尤里安到萨维尼  

The Discovery of Real Contract: From Julian to Savigny

作　　者：柯伟才 

机构地区：[1]南京大学法学院

出　　处：《比较法研究》2016年第6期65-77,共13页Journal of Comparative Law

摘　　要：注释法学家们在解释尤里安和乌尔比安的矛盾片段以及不当得利返还规则的过程中形成了抽象物权合意的观念,经过评注法学派的进一步发展,最终在雨果·多诺鲁斯那里形成了较为系统的抽象交付理论。萨维尼在批判"名义和取得方式"理论的基础之上,借鉴了雨果·多诺鲁斯的理论建立了物权合同理论。物权合同理论的建立不是债法与物法截然区分的结果,而是出于将罗马法体系化的需要。In explaining the rules of condictio and contradiction between Julian and Ulpian,the glossators formed the idea of abstract real agreement. This idea was further developed by commentators,and finally became a systematic abstract transfer theory in Hugo Donellus＇ great Commentary. Based on Donellus＇ thoughts and critique of the titulus and modus theory,Savigny established the real contract theory. The establishment of real contract theory was not an inevitable result of the clear distinction of obligation law and property law,but a need for systematization of Roman civil law.

关 键 词：物权行为 萨维尼 交付 正当原因 

分 类 号：D913[政治法律—民商法学]