王隐《晋书》汤球辑本误录臧荣绪《晋书》考  

A Textual Research into the Mis-inclusion of the Jinshu by Zang Rong-xu in Tang Qiu's Compilation Version of the Jinshu by Wang Yin

作　　者：李建华[1] LI Jian-hua(Luoyang Normal University, Luoyang 471934, China)

机构地区：[1]洛阳师范学院文学院,河南洛阳471934

出　　处：《天中学刊》2017年第5期115-121,共7页Journal of Tianzhong

基　　金：教育部人文社会科学研究青年基金项目(15YJC770016)

摘　　要：先唐典籍引用不题撰者之《晋书》均指王隐《晋书》。入唐后,臧荣绪《晋书》影响力压王隐晋史,傲然居于先唐晋史之首,引用不题撰者之《晋书》皆指臧书。及贞观末房玄龄奉敕所撰《晋书》出,所引不著撰者之《晋书》又专指御撰晋史。后世学者或因疏漏或虽察觉而难以理清这一变化,将唐修《晋书》前之"不题撰者之《晋书》"史料全部归到王隐名下。这一现象从《文选》李善注开始萌芽,至《太平御览》井喷式涌现,这是王隐《晋书》汤球辑本失误之根源所在。以成书时间为限断,王隐《晋书》汤球辑本所载凡东晋成帝咸康七年之后事皆出自臧荣绪《晋书》,咸康六年之前事但辑录于唐修《晋书》之后的史料是否出自臧书已难以考辨。Jinshu untitled author were quoted by other books all referred to Wang Yin＇s Jinshu. Zang Rong-xu＇s Jinshu was in the first place among many Jin Dynasty history book at the beginning of the Tang Dynasty, whose influence surpassed Wang Yin＇s Jinshu, then quoting Jinshu untitled author all refered to Zang Rong-xu＇s Jinshu. All old book was eclipsed when Fang Xuan-ling＇s Jinshu came out, after that, Jinshu untitled author referred to Fang Xuan-ling＇s book. The untitled author Jinshu before the Fang Xuan-ling＇s Jinshu are all classified under the name of Wang yin＇s Jinshu by scholars, wwhether omissions or being aware of and difficult to sort out this change. This phenomenon began to bud in Wenxuan annotated by Li Shah and blowout emerged in Taipingyulan, which is the root causes of error in Wang Yin＇s Jinshu edited by Tang Qiu. In accordance with the time of book writing, the events after Xiankang seventh year of Cheng emperor in Eastern Jin Dynasty all originated Zang Rong-xu＇s Jinshu, the ones before Xiankang sixth year, which were compiled after Fang Xuan-ling＇s Jinshu, were difficult to examine.

关 键 词：王隐《晋书》 臧荣绪《晋书》 古注 类书 误录 

分 类 号：I206.2[文学—中国文学] K05[历史地理—历史学]