微软“黑屏事件”的法律思考  

Juristical Thought about"The Black-screen Event"of Microsoft Company

作　　者：彭兴庭[1] 

机构地区：[1]厦门大学法学院

出　　处：《经济法论丛》2009年第2期174-187,共14页Economic Law Review

摘　　要：对于微软的"黑屏事件",主要存在三种观点,第一种认为是正当的,第二种认为微软滥用了市场支配地位,第三种认为是滥用知识产权。首先,从民法私力救济的角度出发,微软的"黑屏事件"作为一种私力救济行为,不仅不合法,手段不适当,而且损害了社会秩序和公共利益。其次,微软的"黑屏事件"不是一种"滥用市场支配"的行为,不赞成用反垄断法规制。再次,微软"黑屏事件"主要有两种法律规制路径。一条是民法中的权利不得滥用原则,另一条是通过"滥用知识产权"的视角。微软"黑屏事件"是一种"非诚信地主张知识产权",知识产权人滥用了他的"救济权"。There are three viewpoints as regards to'the black-screen event'of Microsoft Company.The first one thinks that it is right,the second one holds that Microsoft Company has abused of dominant position, and the third one believes that Microsoft Company has abused the intellectual property rights.First,from the angle of self-help in the civil law,we think that'the black-screen event'of Microsoft Company,as a self-help action,is not only illegal and unsuitable in its method,but also harmful to the social order and the public interest Next,we do not think that'the black-screen event'is a behavior of'abusing the dominant position',so not approving of regulating it with the antimonopoly law.Third,'the black-screen event'of Microsoft Company mainly has two ways of legal regulation.One is the principle in the civil law that right can not be abused.Another way is from the angle of'abusing the intellectual property rights'.We think that'the black-screen event'of Microsoft Company is a kind of'non-good faith in applying for its intellectual property rights',which is to say that the owner of the intellectual property rights has abused his'relief right'.

关 键 词：黑屏事件 私力救济 滥用 知识产权 

分 类 号：D922.294[政治法律—经济法学] D923.4[政治法律—法学]