增列“以案例为指导”司法审判原则的思考  

Thoughts on Adding “Taking the Case as the Guide” Principle to Judicial Trial

作　　者：匡爱民[1] 严杨[1] 

机构地区：[1]中央民族大学法学院

出　　处：《江西社会科学》2018年第6期153-161,256,共9页Jiangxi Social Sciences

摘　　要：增列"以案例为指导"司法审判原则,正视指导性案例的法律效力和法源地位,有助于持续推进和有力保障案例指导工作,进一步丰富和发展中国特色社会主义司法制度的内涵。确立"以事实为根据,以法律为准绳,以案例为指导"司法审判原则,需要正确认知三者之间的关系,三者之间相互联系、相互渗透、相辅相成,离开其中某两个孤立地理解、解释和运用第三个都是不可取的。Adding "taking the case as the guide" principle to judicial trial, confronting the legal effect and the status of law of guiding cases are helpful to continuously promote and guarantee the case guidance work,and further enrich and develop the connotation of the socialist judicial system with Chinese characteristics. Establishment of the principle of judicial trial "based on facts, taking the law as the criterion and taking the case as the guide" needs to correctly recognize the relationship between the three, which is based on fact, the law as the criterion, the case as the guide. The three are interrelated, penetrated and reinforced with each other, which is not advisable to leave any two of them to understand or to interpret or to apply the third one.

关 键 词：指导性案例 案例指导 以案例为指导 司法审判原则 

分 类 号：D926[政治法律—法学]