保证保险合同纠纷审判思路探析与重构——以100份判决书中的审理差异性为切入点  

Exploration and Reconstruction of Thoughts on Guarantee Insurance Contract Dispute Trial

作　　者：黄穗 HUANG Sui

机构地区：[1]成都高新技术产业开发区人民法院,四川成都610041

出　　处：《四川警察学院学报》2018年第4期37-45,共9页Journal of Sichuan Police College

摘　　要：一直以来,基于保证保险性质的学术讨论都非常的激烈,不同的观点,投射到保证保险合同纠纷审判实践中,形成了四种截然不同的裁判思路,造成法律适用的不统一,影响了司法的稳定性和可预测性。需要科学地对保证保险进行定性。通过对100份判决书的事实部分、判决理由及判项进行统计分析,研究判决的法律适用及裁判标准的差异现象,追根溯源,形成了审理保证保险合同纠纷的"审理三步法"。The academic discussion on the nature of guarantee insurance has long been very intense. Different view-points have caused four different thoughts on trials in judicial practice, affecting the stability and predictability of justice.It is necessary to determine the nature of guarantee insurance scientifically. Three-step approach is suggested based on the statistical analysis of the facts, reasons and judgments of the 100 verdicts.

关 键 词：保证保险合同 审理思路 定性 三步法 

分 类 号：DF5[政治法律—民商法学]