论韩愈对李实的矛盾态度  

On the Contradictory Attitude of Han Yu Toward Li Shi

作　　者：刘静[1] LIU Jing(College of Literature and Journalism, Central South University, Changsha 410012,China)

机构地区：[1]中南大学文学与新闻学院,长沙410012

出　　处：《湖北第二师范学院学报》2019年第1期19-22,共4页Journal of Hubei University of Education

摘　　要：韩愈《上李尚书书》与《顺宗实录》中对李实的评价完全相反,因为《顺宗实录》是韩愈主持修撰,故后世论者均据此发表议论,樊汝霖、魏了翁、王元启、罗大经、顾炎武等,各持己见。然尽管韩愈对李实的态度确存矛盾,考察《顺宗实录》的修撰情况,其中所书之情却未必出自他之手,故就此发表议论有失偏颇。韩愈之"谄"与其文人身份和清客生涯相关,对他的议论纷呈缘于其文人道学双重身份,亦反映了对他接受的广泛性。A letter to Li Shangshu and Faithful Record of Emperor Shun written by Han Yu has contradictory attitude towards Li Shi.Because Faithful Record of Shun Emperor is compiled under the charge of Han Yu,many scholars such as Fan Rulin,Wei Liaoweng,Wang Yuanqi,Luo Dajing,Gu Yangwu discussed it.But,even though there is a contradictory attitude,investigations into compilation of the book shows that the content is not necessarily written by Han Yu himself.So,it is unfair to make judgments based on it.Han Yu's"flattery"has to do with his scholar's identity.The many discussions surrounding him stems from his scholar and neo-Confucianism's dual identity,which also reflects that he is extensively accepted.

关 键 词：韩愈 《上李尚书书》 《顺宗实录》 接受 

分 类 号：I206.2[文学—中国文学]