有正书局《原本加批聊斋志异》批语的价值重估  

The Value Revaluation of the Criticism of Liaozhai Zhiyi Original Manuscript with Criticism by Youzheng Book Company

作　　者：孙大海[1] SUN Da-hai(Department of Chinese Language and Literature,Peking University,Beijing 100871,China)

机构地区：[1]北京大学中文系

出　　处：《北京社会科学》2019年第8期107-117,共11页Social Sciences of Beijing

摘　　要：杨震方先生的两则《王批聊斋志异》跋语,有助于认识《王批聊斋志异》的基本信息,以及其与有正书局《原本加批聊斋志异》的关系。在《王批聊斋志异》暂不可见的背景下,以张菊如《〈王批聊斋志异〉评介》提供的王批为样本,同有正本批语进行比勘可以发现,《原本加批聊斋志异》除结尾删改的个别问题外,相对完整地保留了王批内容。有正本批语可从三个方面补充张文所论王批价值,而那些可以确定为有正书局后期羼入的批语,也可以从接受史的角度发现其意义。Yang Zhenfang's two postscripts of Liaozhai Zhiyi Criticized by Wang are helpful to the understanding of this book's basic information and its relationship with Liaozhai Zhiyi Original Manuscript with Criticism by Youzheng Book Company. Under the background that Liaozhai Zhiyi Criticized by Wang is temporarily unavailable, taking Wang's criticism provided by Zhang Juru's Commentary on Liaozhai Zhiyi Criticized by Wang as a sample, and comparing with the criticism of Youzheng version, we can find that Wang's criticism is relatively completely retained in Liaozhai Zhiyi Original Manuscript with Criticism except for the individual problems of the end deletion. The criticism of Youzheng version can supplement the value of Wang's criticism discussed by Zhang Juru's paper from three aspects. Those criticisms justified as the mixed contents by Youzheng Book Company could reflect their significance from the perspective of acceptance history.

关 键 词：《原本加批聊斋志异》 《王批聊斋志异》 有正本批语 王东序 

分 类 号：I207.41[文学—中国文学]