四库提要“《石林诗话》阴抑元祐”说辨证补论  

Added Explanation about Discussion of Shi Lin Shi Hua Belittling the Yuan You Party in Si Ku Quan Shu

作　　者：冷浪涛 LENG Langtao(College of Literature,Yunnan Normal University,Kunming Yunnan 650500,China)

机构地区：[1]云南师范大学文学院,云南昆明650500

出　　处：《乐山师范学院学报》2020年第11期43-49,共7页Journal of Leshan Normal University

基　　金：云南师范大学校级项目“许印芳《律髓辑要》研究”(ysdyjs2019078)。

摘　　要：“《石林诗话》阴抑元祐”说是《四库全书总目》的代表性观点,这一说法来自方回,它本身存在较大问题,已被郭绍虞、方建新等证明其谬误。但是,考察这些辨证的成果,再通过文献的追溯和文本的细读,笔者认为还有两个问题值得揭出:一是这一说法是方回对叶梦得的非议,方回通过诗的编选和评论、亲党关系的处理、论诗旨趣的曲解等方式制造了这一谬说,而这源于方回论诗极深的门户之见;二是四库馆臣在对方回这一说法的接受上存在着不同的态度,这与四库全书修撰是由官方主持密切相关。Shi Lin Shi Hua belittling the Yuan You Party is a representative point in Si Ku Quan Shu,but this point is wrong,which has been proved by Guo Shaoyu and Fang Jianxin.However,by exploring these discussion results,studying the literature,and reading the text in detail,the author has found 2 problems:first,the idea is a kind of criticism of Ye Mengde by Fang Hui who has produced the idea through compiling and commenting on the poems,dealing with the relationship between parties as well as misinterpreting the poems out of his strong prejudice;secondly,the compilers of Si Ku Quan Shu have different opinions about Fang Hui's idea under the background of the authority's taking charge of the compilation of Si Ku Quan Shu.

关 键 词：《四库全书总目》 《石林诗话》 方回 

分 类 号：G255[文化科学—图书馆学]