《裕憽霆藏书目录》之谜  

Mystery of Yusongting Library Catalogue

作　　者：欧阳健[1] Ouyang Jian

机构地区：[1]福建师范大学文学院

出　　处：《文学与文化》2021年第4期115-127,共13页Literature and Culture Studies

摘　　要：《裕憽霆藏书目录》不是目录学著作,而是书坊库存之清单。裕憽霆有实物可证的藏书,多未见《裕憽霆藏书目录》著录。《裕憽霆藏书目录》有1934年版《新红楼梦》等,可证"己未年(1919)"朱印当为后来补盖。其待填补的年月日,则是通同作弊的证据。利益的驱动,是作伪的最大动力。借裕瑞之名头与《枣窗闲笔》之白纸黑字,以确立曹雪芹"身胖头广"的形象,为的是证明曹雪芹小像之真;借《裕憽霆藏书目录》之著录,则是为了确认《枣窗闲笔》之真,环环相扣,可谓自出机杼。用一个谎言来掩盖另一个谎言,露出的破绽就更多了。Yusongting Library Catalogue is not a book of catalogue, but a list of books in a library. Most of Yusongting’s books available are not recorded in Yusongting Library Catalogue. The New Dream Of Red Mansions of 1928 edition and other books can be found in the catalogue, with the red seal of the year of Jiwei(1919), which should be later stamped. It is a common and universal evidence of forgery,with the date to be filled at will. The driving force of forgery is the interests and benefits. Borrowing the name of Yurui and fabricating the text in Casual Writings by Jujube Window, the author confirmed the image of Cao Xueqin, fat and broad-headed, to be identical to the portrait of Cao Xueqin. It is rather deliberate to hint the authenticity of Casual Writings by Jujube Window by embedding it into Yusongting Library Catalogue. But more flaws will loom up when using one lie to cover another lie.

关 键 词：《枣窗闲笔》 《裕憽霆藏书目录》 曹雪芹画像 胡适 李祖韩 史树青 

分 类 号：G256[文化科学—图书馆学]