破坏监管秩序罪的司法实践反思  

Reflection on Judicial Practice of The Crime of Disrupting Supervision Order

作　　者：马浩云 张俊红 Ma Haoyun;Zhang Junhong(Guizhou Police College,Guiyang 550005,China)

机构地区：[1]贵州警察学院,贵州贵阳550005

出　　处：《贵州警察学院学报》2022年第5期13-19,共7页Journal of Guizhou Police College

摘　　要：破坏监管秩序罪的规定已然不能完全适应狱内监管新变化。对破坏监管秩序罪的司法文书案例进行整理统计,从行为人群体特征、犯罪行为特征、刑罚特征三个维度出发,分析出构成破坏监管秩序罪行为人群体特征和司法实践状况。整理案例发现认定破坏监管秩序罪的重点在对行为是否达到“严重”的判断,与故意伤害罪的想象竞合也是该罪在司法实践中的表现特征。面对该罪的运行相关问题,从该罪的设计问题、该罪的认定问题和该罪的区分问题三个角度提出相应对策和建议。The provisions of the crime of disrupting the order of supervision c-an no longer fully adapt to the new changes in prison supervision.The judicial document cases of the crime of disrupting the regulatory order are sorted out and counted,and the group characteristics and judicial practice of the perpetrators of the crime of disrupting the regulatory order are analyzed from the three dimensions of the group characteristics of the actors,the characteristics of the criminal behavior and the characteristics of the punishment.Sorting out the cases found that the focus of identifying the crime of disrupting the regulatory order is to judge whether the behavior is"serious";The imaginative concurrence with the crime of intentional injury is also the characteristic of the crime in judicial practice.Facing the problems related to the operation of crime,this paper puts forward corresponding countermeasures and suggestions from three aspects:the design of crime,the identification of crime and the distinction of crime.

关 键 词：破坏监管秩序罪 司法实践 法律完善 

分 类 号：D914[政治法律—刑法学]