胡惟庸通倭案真伪再辨析  

A Textual Research about the True and FalseCase on Hu Weiyong's Colluded with Japanese Pirates

作　　者：刘扬[1] 黄霞[2] LIU Yang;HUANG Xia(School of History&Culture,China West Normal University,Nanchong,Sichuan 637009;Mianyang Teachers'College,Mianyang,Sichuan 621000)

机构地区：[1]西华师范大学历史文化学院,四川南充637009 [2]绵阳师范学院,四川绵阳621000

出　　处：《绵阳师范学院学报》2023年第4期113-120,共8页Journal of Mianyang Teachers＇ College

基　　金：四川省社会科学重点研究基地区域文化研究中心项目“史实本相与虚构认知”(QYYJC20011);西华师范大学教学改革项目“跨学科融合教学背景下历史信息化教学人才培养模式研究”(403752);四川省基础教育数字化教学人才培养模式研究(CJF20031)成果。

摘　　要：从史料学、证据学、逻辑学的视角考察胡惟庸通倭案,罗列关于胡惟庸通倭案系真案、伪案两派观点的中日代表论著,多角度辨析两派依托的文献,分析伪案一说流行的原因。由于缺乏有价值的史料和证据,加之逻辑推理不足,所以,“胡惟庸通倭案是伪案”不成立。Proving"Hu Weiyong colluded with Japanese pirates is a pseudo case"cannot be established in terms of historical data,law of evidence and logistics.Listing two different viewpoints form China and Japan about Hu Weiyong colluded with Japanese pirates,analyzing the popular reasons of"Hu Weiyong colluded with Japanese pirates is a pseudo case",comparing the historical documents which two different viewpoints based on.Because of lacking the value of historical documents and evidential effect and logicality,"Hu Weiyong colluded with Japanese pirates is a pseudo case"that cannot be established.

关 键 词：胡惟庸 通倭案 史料学 证据学 逻辑学 

分 类 号：K302[历史地理—历史学]