分裂的领域:读《什么是建筑史》  

A Field Divided:Reading What is Architectural History?

作　　者：王为[1,2] WANG Wei

机构地区：[1]东南大学建筑学院 [2]东南大学建筑历史与理论研究所

出　　处：《建筑师》2023年第4期103-108,共6页The Architect

摘　　要：安德鲁·里奇2010年的著作《什么是建筑史》探讨了建筑历史编纂学这一研究领域的发展历史与当代境况。本文对书中涉及的建筑史的起源、框架、材料、应用等主题进行梳理并解释,并由此聚焦于其中关于“学科性”的讨论;再结合文化史等其他历史学分支的跨学科趋势,进一步指出“内部史”与“外部史”两种范式之间的深刻分歧正带给建筑史研究同样的挑战与启示,而这也是如今专业史写作亟待回应的方法论难题。Andrew Leach’s 2010 book What is Architectural History?explores the historical development and contemporary condition of architectural historiography as a research field.This paper sorts out and interprets a series of topics including origins,frameworks,materials,and applications of architectural history covered in the book,with a focus on the discussion of“Disciplinarity”.In the light of the interdisciplinary trends in other branches of history,such as Cultural History,it further points out that profound differences between two paradigms of“internal history”and“external history”are bringing the same challenges and enlightenments to architectural history research,which is also a methodological problem that needs to be responded to in today’s professional historiography.

关 键 词：建筑历史 建筑史编纂 建筑理论 历史研究方法论 学科性 

分 类 号：TU-098.6[建筑科学—建筑理论]