中共中央转战陕北时期《任弼时年谱》《任弼时传》若干史实考证——兼论中共领袖人物年谱、传记编写的“打通”问题  

An Examination of Several Historical Facts in A Chronicle of Ren Bishi's Life and A Biography of Ren Bishi Concerning the Period from 1947 to 1948——Also on"Keeping Consistency"between the Chronicles and Biographies for Party Leaders

作　　者：刘思源 LIU Siyuan(University of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences,Fangshan,Beijing 102488)

机构地区：[1]中国社会科学院大学,北京房山102488

出　　处：《中国延安干部学院学报》2023年第1期77-85,共9页Journal of China Executive Leadership Academy Yan’an

摘　　要：最新出版的《任弼时年谱》《任弼时传》,所记1947—1948年中共中央转战陕北若干史实存在错讹及相互矛盾之处。蒋介石1947年2月末并没有到西安部署进攻延安;前东原会议日期应为1947年8月23日;中央纵队并没有实际到过大会坪等。《任弼时年谱》《任弼时传》的问题在其他领袖人物的年谱、传记中同样存在。中共领袖人物年谱、传记存在三种矛盾情况:同一本著作内部相互矛盾,同一人物年谱、传记之间相互矛盾,不同人物年谱、传记之间相互矛盾。中共领袖人物年谱、传记应全面“打通”。The newly published books,A Chronicle of Ren Bishi's Life and A Biography of Ren Bishi contain er-rors and contradictions on some historical facts concerning the period when the Party Central Committee trans-ferred and fought across northern Shaanxi(1947-1948).To name just some:Chiang Kai-shek did not go to Xi'an in person to deploy the offensive on Yan'an at the end of February 1947;the Qian Dongyuan Meeting was held on August 23,1947;the Central Column did not arrive at Da Huiping.Similar mistakes can also be found in the chron-icles and biographies for other leaders.The contradictions in the chronicles and biographies can be classified into the following three types:inconsistencies within the same work,inconsistencies between the chronicle and biogra-phy for the same figure,and inconsistencies among chronicles and biographies for different figures.Accordingly,it is imperative to achieve consistency when compiling chronicles and biographies for Party leaders.

关 键 词：任弼时年谱 任弼时传 考证 毛泽东 周恩来 

分 类 号：D231[政治法律—政治学] K26[政治法律—中共党史]