Apple、Coros、Mi对急性运动心率信号监测的稳定性与可靠性对比研究  

A Comparative Study on the Stability and Reliability of the Monitoring of Acute Exercise Heart Rate Signals by Apple,Coros and Mi

作　　者：龚铭漪 张义万 黄志强 Cong Mingy;Zhang Yiwan;Huang Zhiqiang(College of Physical Education,Hubei Second Normal University,Wuhan 430205,China)

机构地区：[1]湖北第二师范学院体育学院,湖北武汉430205 [2]湖北第二师范学院全民健身与健康促进中心,湖北武汉430205

出　　处：《体育科技文献通报》2023年第12期281-284,共4页Bulletin of Sport Science & Technology

摘　　要：目的:通过分析对比三款运动手环对急性运动心率信号监测的稳定性与可靠性,为科学训练以及大众健身提供参考。方法:选取40名被试者,随机分成高强度间歇运动一组(HIIT1,15人)、高强度间歇运动二组(HIIT2,15人)、一分钟原地高抬腿跑组(LR,10人)共三组,同时佩带三款运动手环(同款两块,左右各一块)与Polar心率带。左右手同款手环监测对比的稳定性,三款运动手环与“金标准”Polar对比得手环监测可靠性。研究结果:稳定性结果显示,Apple1与Apple2、Coros1与Coros2、Mi1与Mi 2相关系数分别为0.951、0.817、0.804,均P<0.01;可靠性结果显示,Ploar与Apple、Coros、Mi相关系数分别为0.941、0.754、0.762,均P<0.01。研究结论:在高强度间歇运动中三款运动手环稳定性为Apple>Coros>Mi,可靠性为Apple>Mi>Coros。其中,Coros整体低估心率,Mi在心率陡变时波动较大,因此,对急性心率的监控首选Apple,其次为Coros、Mi。The objective of this paper is to study the stability and reliability of three sports bracelets on the monitoring of acute exercise heart rate signals,and to provide a reference for monitoring such exercise heart rate.Methods:Forty participants were randomly divided into 1 group of high-intensity interval exercise(HIIT1,15 people),2 groups of high-intensity interval exercise(HIT2,15 people),and one minute leg high running group(LR,10 people),while wearing three sports bracelets(two pieces of the same model,one on the left and right)and a Polar heart rate belt.The same bracelet monitoring of the left and right hands is more stable,and the three sports bracelets are compared with the"gold standard"Polar to achieve the reliability of bracelet monitoring.Results:(a)The stability results showed that the correlation coefficients between Applel and Apple2,Corosl and Coros2,and Mil and Mi 2 were 0.951,0.817 and 0.804,respectively,all of which were P<0.01.(b)The reliability results showed that the correlation coefficients between Ploar and Apple,Coros and Mi were 0.941,0.754,and 0.762,respectively,with a P<0.01.Conclusion:In high-intensity interval exercise,the stability of the three sports bracelets were Apple>Coros>Mi,while the reliability were Apple>Mi>Coros(>indicates better).Coros underestimates heart rate overall,and Mi fluctuates greatly during sudden changes in heart rate.Apple is the first choice for monitoring acute heart rate,followed by Coros and Mi.

关 键 词：运动手环 急性运动 心率监测 稳定性 可靠性 

分 类 号：G804[文化科学—运动人体科学]