中国学术期刊撤稿论文被引的原因分析及应对策略  

Citation analysis and strategies of withdrawal papers in chinese academic journals

作　　者：唐晓莲 邹小勇 张元媛 胡晓霖 舒安琴 冷怀明 TANG Xiaolian;ZOU Xiaoyong;ZHANG Yuanyuan;HU Xiaolin;SHU Anqin;LENG Huaiming(China Pharmacy Editing and Publishing Center,Chongqing University Affiliated Cancer Hospital,400042,Chongqing,China)

机构地区：[1]重庆大学附属肿瘤医院《中国药房》编辑出版中心,重庆400042

出　　处：《编辑学报》2023年第5期473-477,共5页Acta Editologica

基　　金：中国高校科技期刊研究会专项基金课题(CUJS2023-D13);重庆市高校期刊研究会“渝编-仁和基金”项目立项课题(CQLX2020-14);重庆市科学技术期刊编辑学会2020年度科研项目(CQKJQKXH20200016)。

摘　　要：本文采用中国知网和中文期刊学术平台综合检索撤稿声明,统计论文撤稿原因及撤稿声明刊登后的被引频次,比较2个数据库对撤稿论文的处理情况,检索撤稿论文在网络平台和期刊官网中的状态,并对施引文献的引用态度进行分析,以期从施引期刊、数据库、施引者等角度分析撤稿论文被引的原因,并提出应对对策。结果发现,撤稿论文所涉主题关注度较高、施引者引用不当、施引期刊难以把握撤稿论文的被引、数据库间撤稿流程存在差异是撤稿论文被引的主要原因。因此,建议提升作者科研数据管理意识,引入全文本引文分析,判断撤稿论文被引用的学术价值,加强各环节学术不端行为的监管力度,规范数据库间撤稿流程和网络平台、期刊官网撤稿要求。This article uses CNKI and the Chinese journal academic platform to comprehensively search for withdrawal statements,calculate the reasons for withdrawal and citation frequency,compare the processing of withdrawal papers in the two databases,search for the status of withdrawal papers in the online platform and journal official website directory,and analyze the citation attitude of cited literature,in order to analyze the reasons for withdrawal papers being cited from thecited journal,databases,introducer,etc.,and propose countermeasures.The results showed that high level of attention to the topics involved in the withdrawn papers,improper citation by the cited authors,difficulty in controlling the citation of withdrawn papers by the cited journals,and differences in the withdrawal process between databases.Therefore,it is recommended to enhance the author’s awareness of scientific research data management,introduce full-text citation analysis,judge the academic value of the withdrawn papers being cited,strengthen the supervision of academic misconduct in all aspects,standardize the withdrawal process between databases and the withdrawalrequirements on online platforms and journal official websites.

关 键 词：学术期刊 撤稿论文 引文分析 对策 

分 类 号：G237.5[文化科学]