“同人刊物”与“学术公器”:中国现代学术期刊的双重角色及其契合机制  

“Journal of an Academic Community” and “Academic Instrument”:The Dual Roles and Integration Mechanism of Modern Chinese Academic Journals

作　　者：陈义报 CHEN Yibao(Editorial Department of the Journal,Huzhou University,Huzhou 313000,China)

机构地区：[1]湖州师范学院学报编辑部,浙江湖州313000

出　　处：《湖州师范学院学报》2024年第5期85-94,共10页Journal of Huzhou University

基　　金：教育部人文社会科学研究项目“20世纪二三十年代学术期刊与学术共同体的互动”(20YJAZH014)。

摘　　要：中国现代学术期刊兼具“同人刊物”与“学术公器”双重角色。“同人刊物”通常由具有共同学术理念的学者群体创办,强调特定的学术立场和流派特色。而“学术公器”则作为广泛交流的平台,反映学术共同体的多样性,并促进不同研究的交流。这两种角色的契合得益于“群而不党”的办刊机制、“编研一体”的期刊与共同体融合机制以及“期刊承认”等同于“学术共同体承认”的学术评价机制。这些机制共同构建了中国现代学术期刊在知识生产与传播中的重要角色,同时也为中国现代学术期刊的发展与繁荣奠定了坚实基础。Modern Chinese academic journals play dual roles as both“journal of an academic community”and“academic instrument”.The former is usually founded by a group of scholars who share common academic beliefs,emphasizing specific academic standpoints and school characteristics.The latter serves as a platform for extensive exchanges,reflecting the diversity of the academic community and facilitating communication among different studies.The two roles are integrated as the result of the editorial philosophy of“unity without partisanship”,the editorial composition of“integration of editing and research”,and the evaluation mechanism where“journal recognition”is equivalent to“recognition by the academic community”.These mechanisms jointly promote the important role of modern Chinese academic journals in knowledge production and dissemination,and lay a solid foundation for the development and prosperity of modern Chinese academic journals.

关 键 词：同人刊物 学术公器 现代学术期刊 

分 类 号：G239.29[文化科学]