中文期刊论文层级量化差异研究——以图书情报领域为例  

Study on Quantitative Differences in the Hierarchy of Chinese Journal Papers: Case Study of the Field of Library and Information Science

作　　者：张慧[1] 程雨琦 Zhang Hui;Cheng Yuqi(School of Cultural Heritage and Information Management,Shanghai University,Shanghai 200444)

机构地区：[1]上海大学文化遗产与信息管理学院,上海200444

出　　处：《情报探索》2024年第7期102-109,共8页Information Research

基　　金：上海市哲学社会科学青年基金项目“新文科建设背景下我国人文社科学术论文的量化关联特征研究”(项目编号:2021ETQ003)成果之一。

摘　　要：[目的/意义]探索图书情报领域中文期刊论文量化特征层级差异,为论文评价研究提供参考。[方法/过程]以图书情报领域为例,获取CNKI和人大复印报刊资料官网数据,划分为复印报刊资料、CSSCI和其他期刊三大层级,从被引次数、基金资助、论文主题三个方面分析量化特征差异。[结果/结论]三大层级在载文量、基金资助等方面有所进步,第三层级进步最为显著,但愈发难以获得第一层级的青睐;第一层级转载对论文被引有极大推动作用,转载论文选题区分度大,有一定的主题倾向;第一层级对第二、三层级论文的主题引导分别以研究主题和研究方法为主。层级差异依然显著,但不应忽略第三层级论文的价值,第三层级论文在一些量化指标上进步明显,把关论文创新性是未来提高第三层级论文质量的重点。[Purpose/significance]The paper aims to explore the hierarchical differences in quantitative features of Chinese journal papers in the field of library and information science,and provide reference for paper evaluation research.[Method/process]Taking the field of library and information science as an example,the paper obtained data from CNKI and articles reprinted in the RUC Reprint Journal,which were divided into three levels:reprinted journals,CSSCI,and other journals,and analyzed quantitative feature differences from three aspects:citation,funding,and theme.[Result/conclusion]All three levels have made progress in terms of publication volume and funding support,with the third level being the most significant,but it is becoming increasingly difficult to win the favor of the first level;the first level of reprinting has a great promoting effect on the citation of papers,with a high degree of topic differentiation and a certain thematic tendency in reprinted papers;the first level focuses on guiding the research topic and research methods for the second and the third level papers,respectively.The hierarchical differences are still significant,but the value of the third level papers should not be ignored.The third level papers have made significant progress in some quantitative indicators,and ensuring the innovation of papers is the key to improving the quality of the third level papers in the future.

关 键 词：层级结构 量化特征 被引次数 基金资助 主题演化 

分 类 号：G250.2[文化科学—图书馆学]