《乙弗玉墓志》《刘媚墓志》辨伪  

Distinguishing the Authenticity of The Epitaph of Yifu Yu and The Epitaph of Liu Mei

作　　者：王胜明[1] 张莹莹 WANG Sheng-ming;ZHANG Ying-ying(School of Chinese Language and Literature,China West Normal University,Nanchong 637009,China)

机构地区：[1]西华师范大学文学院,四川南充637009

出　　处：《西华师范大学学报（哲学社会科学版）》2024年第4期107-116,共10页Journal of China West Normal University:Philosophy & Social Sciences

基　　金：国家社会科学基金重点项目“河洛新出墓志汇集、整理与研究”(19AZW011)。

摘　　要：《隋唐五代墓志汇编》(山西卷)第一册所录久视元年(700)《柳行满妻乙弗玉墓志》《柳行满妻刘媚墓志》存在诸如志文大量抄袭他志、对拥有郡君封号的志主称呼不当、墓志盖题与首题国名不协、同墓不应出土同时刻制的三通鸳鸯志等问题,此类现象说明《柳行满妻乙弗玉墓志》《柳行满妻刘媚墓志》并非唐人原创,而很可能是今人以久视元年(700)《柳行满及妻刘媚乙弗玉合祔志墓志》所述柳行满妻乙弗玉、刘媚行迹为蓝本,大量抄袭久视元年(700)《柳行满及妻刘媚乙弗玉合祔志墓志》、万岁通天二年(697)《韦君妻王婉墓志》、仪凤二年(677)《贾整及妻陈氏墓志》文本赝造的伪志。The Epitaph of Liu Xingman's Wife Yifu Yu and The Epitaph of Liu Xingman's Wife Liu Mei recorded in the first volume of The Compilation of Epitaphs of Sui,Tang and Five Dynasties Sui,Tang and Five Dynasties(Shanxi Volume)in the first year of Jiushi(AD700)has some problems,such as a large number of plagiarism of other people's tomb inscriptions,improper addressing of the epitaph owners who hold the title of county lord,inconsistency of the country name in the stele inscriptions on both the cover title and the first title of the epitaphs and simultaneously carved three epitaphs of the husband and his two wives that were unearthed in the same tomb.These phenomena indicate that both The Epitaph of Liu Xingman's Wife Yifu Yu and The Epitaph of Liu Xingman's Wife Liu Mei are not original works of the Tang Dynasty,it's likely that those two epitaphs are fake ones based on the identity information and life experiences described in The Epitaph of Liu Xingman and His Wives Yifu Yu and Liu Mei,and the two epitaphs extensively plagiarize the inscriptions of The Epitaph of Liu Xingman's Wives Liu Mei and Yifu Yu curved in the first year of Jiushi(AD 700),The Epitaph of Wei Jun's Wife Wang Wan curved in the second year of Wansui Tongtian(AD 697),and The Epitaph of Jia Zheng and His Wife Chens curved in the second year of Yifeng(AD 677).

关 键 词：《柳行满墓志》 《刘媚墓志》 《乙弗玉墓志》 伪志 

分 类 号：K877.2[历史地理—考古学及博物馆学]