国际软件期刊发展现状及其出版政策研究  

Analysis on development status and publishing policies of international software journals

作　　者：关琳琳 马瀚青 王晓醉[3] GUAN Linlin;MA Hanqing;WANG Xiaozui(Editorial Office of Big Earth Data,Society and Journal Department,Aerospace Information Research Institute,Chinese Academy of Sciences,9 Dengzhuang South Road,Haidian District,Beijing 100094,China;Editorial Office of Remote Sensing Technology and Application,Document and Information Center,Northwest Institute of Eco-Environment and Resources,Chinese Academy of Sciences,8 Middle Tianshui Road,Chengguan District,Lanzhou 730000,China;Editorial Office of Geo-Spatial Information Science,Wuhan University,299 Baiyi Road,Wuchang District,Wuhan 430072,China)

机构地区：[1]中国科学院空天信息创新研究院学会与期刊部《地球大数据(英文)》编辑部,北京市100094 [2]中国科学院西北生态环境资源研究院文献情报中心《遥感技术与应用》编辑部,甘肃省兰州市730000 [3]武汉大学《地球空间信息科学学报(英文)》编辑部,湖北省武汉市430072

出　　处：《中国科技期刊研究》2024年第11期1558-1570,共13页Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals

基　　金：中国科学院自然科学期刊编辑研究会2023年研究课题“科技期刊支撑开放软件与代码的政策和实践”(YJH202307)。

摘　　要：【目的】通过对国际软件期刊的发展现状和出版政策进行调研与分析,为我国软件期刊的创办与发展提供指导,并为我国科技期刊制定科学软件和代码的开放共享政策提供参考和借鉴。【方法】采用网络调查法和内容分析法,对全球软件期刊发展状况进行调查,并对代表性国际软件期刊出版政策进行梳理,提炼软件论文出版质量控制政策的框架与特性要素。【结果】全球共创办有46种软件期刊,大型出版机构和创新出版商推动其发展。通过对20种代表性软件期刊的调查,发现软件期刊的出版政策着重强调软件与代码的存储、软件论文结构标准、同行评议模式与评审标准。此外,软件期刊还采取多种合作模式,以提升期刊质量和影响力。【结论】国际科技期刊通过探索软件论文出版模式,积极推出数据、软件和代码的共享策略,进一步促进科学研究过程的开放、透明、可重复、可复现。我国应抓住开源软件进入开放科学的历史机遇,大力建设软件期刊,并逐级制定科技期刊软件和代码的开放共享政策,培育软件共享文化,促进我国开放科学的全面深入发展。[Purposes]By investigating and analyzing the development status and publishing policies of international software journals,this study aims to provide guidance for the establishment and development of software journals in China and offer references for formulating open sharing policies of research software and code for China's scientific journals.[Methods]Using online survey and content analysis methods,we investigated the development status of global software journals.We sorted out the publishing policies of representative international software journals to extract the framework and characteristic elements of quality control policies for software paper publication.[Findings]A total of 46 software journals have been established,promoted by large publishing institutions and innovative publishers.The investigation of 20 representative software journals shows that their publishing policies emphasize software and code storage,structural standards of software papers,peer review models,and evaluation criteria.Additionally,software journals adopt various cooperation models to enhance their quality and influence.[Conclusions]International scientific journals actively promote strategies for sharing data,software,and code by exploring the publishing models of software papers,further promoting openness,transparency,repeatability,and reproducibility in the scientific research process.China should seize the historical opportunity of open source software entering open science,make significant efforts to establish software journals,and progressively implement open sharing policies for software and code in scientific journals.This will cultivate a culture of software sharing and contribute to the comprehensive and in-depth development of open science in the country.

关 键 词：科学软件 软件论文 数据论文 代码共享 数据共享 开放科学 

分 类 号：G23[文化科学]