“重实体,轻程序”命题的语境分析——兼论程序正义问题  

Context Analysis of the "Value Substance,Devalue Procedure" Thesis:On the Problem of Procedural Justice Incidentally

作　　者：邹立君[1] 

机构地区：[1]南京大学法学院,江苏南京210093

出　　处：《法制与社会发展》2008年第4期40-46,共7页Law and Social Development

摘　　要："重实体,轻程序"作为一个法学命题,是一个已被接受的主张、某种标准的区分、还是被编织起来的观念之网结?这些并未予以充分言明,或许只有参照它所服务的理论目的,我们才能有所理解。在其语境当中考察,可以发现"重实体,轻程序"的问题至少有着描述上与判断上的难题。运用所谓"极性原则"这一理论分析工具,并结合"程序正义"观念来分析,可以使人们认识到要克服"重实体,轻程序"的问题,某种表达式的转换是最为根本的。＂ Value substance, devalue procedure＂ as a legal thesis is an accepted claim, or some differentiation of criterion, or the net of idea which had been knitted？ No one has made it clear yet, maybe only by refer to the theoretical purpose it serves, one can understand it. Exploring in the context it used, one can find that the problem of ＂value substance, devalue procedure＂ has some difficulties of description and of judgement. By using the principle of polarity as the means of analysis, and by combining it with the idea of ＂procedural justice＂, one can make people recognize that if they want to overcome the problem of ＂value substance, devalue procedure＂, changing the mode of expression is of the most importance.

关 键 词：“重实体 轻程序” 程序正义 实体正义 极性原则 

分 类 号：D90[政治法律—法学理论]