儒家“仁”之伦理与关怀伦理可否兼容?——关于这场争论的评述  

Is Confucianism Compatible with Care Ethics?——A Summarize Study

作　　者：范伟伟[1] 

机构地区：[1]清华大学哲学系,北京100084

出　　处：《伦理学研究》2009年第3期36-40,共5页Studies in Ethics

基　　金：国家社会科学基金青年项目"女性主义公民资格与社会正义"(08CZX034)

摘　　要：关怀伦理与儒家"仁"之伦理能否兼容?学者们通过这两种伦理学对"仁"与"关怀"等概念的解读;对原则和普遍性的批判与再批判;对传统的脱离或依归;对女性主义立场的态度等方面得出截然不同的结论。李成杨认为儒家伦理与关怀伦理能够兼容,二者可以整合为一种全新的伦理学形式。而斯塔和苑莉均等学者则从不同的角度对李成杨的观点进行批驳,表示二者虽然有某种程度上的相似性,但绝不具有兼容的根基与可能。Is Confucianism compatible with care ethics？ Three scholars resulted the opposite conclusions by unscrambling the conceptions of Jen and care, criticizing and re - creticizing the universalism of principle, beyond or toward to tradition and the Position of femi- nist or not. Chengyang Li thought that the two ethics are compatible, and they could learn from each other and use for references and create a fire - new ethics theory. But Daniel Star and Lijun Yuan criticized the views of Li from different perspective, and rejected the possibility of compatibility of two whereas they expressed some common points of view.

关 键 词：关怀伦理 儒家伦理 关怀 仁 

分 类 号：B82-09[哲学宗教—伦理学]