h指数在人文社会学科中的评价表征能力：期刊视角的实证  

h-index＇s Characterization Ability in Humanities and Social Science：An Empirical Study from the Perspective of Journals

作　　者：赵星[1] 高小强[1] 周春雷[2] 

机构地区：[1]重庆大学经济与工商管理学院,重庆400030 [2]武汉大学信息管理学院,武汉430072

出　　处：《情报学报》2010年第6期1125-1131,共7页Journal of the China Society for Scientific and Technical Information

基　　金：重庆大学研究生创新团队建设项目“信息计量学研究团队”（批准号：200909C0012）成果.中国科学技术信息研究所的武夷山先生对文中的概念表述及分析讨论都提出了宝贵修改意见,重庆大学经济与工商管理学院的何培女士帮助收集了部分数据,特此感谢.

摘　　要：对前人理论推导和实证分析的文献研究表明：h指数可能具有对传统定量评价指标和定性评价方法的综合表征能力。以法学,管理学,教育学,经济学,历史学,马克思主义,民族学,体育学,图书馆、情报与文献学,新闻学与传播学,艺术学,语言学,哲学,政治学,中国文学共15个学科的346种期刊为样本,研究h指数的表征能力在人文社会学科的具体表现及差异。结果显示：h指数的表征能力在体育学等13个学科中都有不同程度体现,但在马克思主义和民族学没有得到证实。此能力没有表现出与学科期刊规模相关,但与学科性质是＂社会＂、＂人文＂或＂哲学＂有粗略关联,并在图书馆、情报与文献学和管理学内不同水平期刊间保持稳定,但在法学等6个学科存在差异。Based on previous theory and empirical research,we suppose that h-index may have a comprehensive characterization ability of the traditional quantitative evaluation indices and qualitative evaluation methods.Taking 346 journals including Law,Management,Education,Economics,History,Marxist,Ethnology,Sports science,Library and Information science,Journalism and Communication,Art studies,Linguistics,Philosophy,Politics,Chinese literature,totally 15 disciplines as example,the concrete manifestation and difference of h-index＇s characterization ability in Humanities and Social science is studied.The results show that h-index＇s characterization ability is,reflected Sports science and other 13 disciplines in varying degrees,except Marxism and Ethnology.A rudeness association between h-index＇s characterization ability and discipline nature has been found,but there is no correlation between h- index＇s characterization ability and journal scale of discipline.Moreover,h-index＇s characterization ability can keep stable at different levels of journals in Library and Information science as well as in Management.But there are differences in Law and other 6 disciplines.

关 键 词：H指数 人文社会学科 学术评价 期刊 表征能力 

分 类 号：G255.2[文化科学—图书馆学]