大学排行榜还是股票涨跌板--基于2012至2015年“中国高职高专院校竞争力排行榜”的定量分析  

University Rankings or Stock Up-down Board——Based on the Quantitative Analysis of“Competitiveness Rankings of China Higher Vocational Colleges”2012-2015

作　　者：伍红军[1,2] 秦虹[3,4,1] 

机构地区：[1]浙江工业职业技术学院高职教育研究所 [2]绍兴市区域教育与产业发展研究中心 [3]浙江工业职业技术学院 [4]浙江工业职业技术学院科研处

出　　处：《职业技术教育》2015年第27期50-55,共6页Vocational and Technical Education

基　　金：2015年度浙江省哲学社会科学规划课题“中国高校分布的政治中心群聚现象研究”(15NDJC284YBM),主持人:伍红军

摘　　要：武汉大学中国科学评价中心于2012年首次推出的"中国高职高专院校竞争力排行榜",是目前唯一针对高职院校进行综合评价的排名。对其2012-2015年四年评价结果的定量分析发现,该排行榜的稳定性不够,各院校在年度之间的位次动荡太过剧烈;择优性不足,优秀高职院校在排名中毫无优势可言;诸多不合逻辑甚至脱离常识的异常现象频现,严重影响到该排行榜的公信力。Chinese Science and Technology Evaluation Center of Wuhan University came up with the first ＂Competitiveness Rankings of China Higher Vocational Colleges＂ in 2012, which is so far the only comprehensive ranking assessment institution for higher vocational colleges. Quantitative analysis of its four-year evaluation results of 2012-2015 shows that the ranking lacks its stability. The ranking place of the same college varies too much among the years. And it has its deficiency in selecting the superior. Those highlighted higher vocational colleges have no real advantages at all; and there are even many illogical abnormal phenomena deviating from the common sense, which seriously affect the credibility of the rankings.

关 键 词：中国高职高专院校竞争力排行榜 指标体系 数据来源 公信力 

分 类 号：G718.5[文化科学—职业技术教育学]