刑事案件另案处理概念及其适用范围再议——以《关于规范刑事案件“另案处理”适用的指导意见》为参照  

Reconsideration on the Concept and Application Range about Separate Action in Criminal Procedure——“The Guidance for Standardization of Separate Action in Criminal Procedure” for Reference

作　　者：胡之芳[1] 

机构地区：[1]湖南科技大学法学院,湖南湘潭411201

出　　处：《法学杂志》2016年第9期103-113,共11页Law Science Magazine

基　　金：国家社科基金课题"刑事诉讼另案处理程序实证研究"(项目编号:12CFX046)的阶段性成果

摘　　要：刑事诉讼客体的关联性和可分性是适用另案处理的前提。对于一个关联性诉讼案件而言,诉讼客体的可分性贯穿诉讼始终而非仅限于某一诉讼阶段;诉讼客体的关联性既包括"人"的关联性也包括"事"的关联性,因此另案处理不仅适用于数人一罪和数人数罪的案件,也应当适用于一人数罪的案件;考虑另案处理适用的具体情形应以价值目标为指引,只有更有利于刑事诉讼价值目标的实现时才能适用另案处理,从而严格且合理地设定刑事案件另案处理的界限。The separability and relevance of the objects of criminal proceedings is the precondition of a separate action in criminal procedure. For a criminal procedure with relevant cases, the separability of the objects of criminal proceedings is demonstrated on all the stages of criminal procedure rather than some special stage; The relevance of the objects of criminal proceedings includes both the relevance of ＂person＂ and ＂ criminal facts＂, therefore a separate action is applied not only in a circumstance of ＂one person one crime＂ and ＂ many persons many crimes ＂ but also in a circumstance of ＂one person many crimes＂ ; We should take the value goal of proceedings as a guidance of application scope of separate action in criminal procedure. Only on condition that it is beneficial to realize the value goals of criminal procedure can we divide a case into separate actions, which set a strict and reasonable boundary for the application of separate action in criminal procedure.

关 键 词：另案处理 刑事诉讼客体 可分性 关联性 诉讼价值 

分 类 号：D925.2[政治法律—诉讼法学]