图书馆学硕士学位论文质量的间接测度——基于引文特征与论文效用的视角  

Indirect Evaluation of Quality of Master’s Degree Thesis in Library Science:Based on The Characteristics of Citation and The Utility of Papers

作　　者：卢文辉 叶继元[1] Lu Wenhui;Ye Jiyuan(School of Information Management,Nanjing University)

机构地区：[1]南京大学信息管理学院,南京210023

出　　处：《图书馆》2019年第4期13-23,共11页Library

基　　金：教育部人文社会科学专项任务项目(科研诚信和学风建设)重大课题"学术规范和学科"方法论研究(项目编号:11JDXF001)研究成果

摘　　要：文章通过建立一个由引文形式、引文特征和论文效用等指标组成的评价体系,间接评价了2014—2016年间的344篇图书馆学硕士学位论文的质量,并对各引文特征指标与硕士论文被引量与下载量之间的关系进行了分析。研究发现各硕士学位论文在引文及其效用方面仍存在许多问题,如著录不规范、引文数量差距大、语种单一化、被引率普遍较低等;论文引文特征与论文效用之间存在一定关系,如英文引文量、电子资源引用量与论文下载量、被引量之间存在显著正相关关系,引文数量的多少与论文下载量和被引量相关性不大等。研究最终得出了论文质量评价结果,并从引文的角度对如何提高图书馆学硕士学位论文质量提出了建议。This paper establishes an evaluation system consisting of citation form,citation characteristics and thesis utility.It indirectly evaluates the quality of 344 master’s theses in library science from 2014 to 2016,and analyzes the relationship between each citation characteristic index and the amount of citation and download of master’s theses.The study finds that there are still many problems in citation and its utility,such as nonstandard description,large gap in citation quantity,monotonous language,low citation rate and so on.There is a certain relationship between citation characteristics and paper effectiveness,such as the number of English citations,the number of electronic resources citations and the number of papers downloaded,citations are positively correlated.There is little correlation between the number of citations and the number of papers downloaded and cited.Finally,the paper gets the evaluation result of the thesis quality,and puts forward some suggestions to improve the quality of the master’s thesis of library science from the angle of citation.

关 键 词：硕士学位论文 论文质量 图书馆学 引文分析法 论文质量评价 

分 类 号：G250[文化科学—图书馆学]