强拿硬要型寻衅滋事罪与抢劫罪辨析  

Analyze Extortion-Type Public Disturbance and Robbery

作　　者：成月华 许黎黎 Chen Yuehua;Xu Lili(People's Procuratorate of Pudong New Area,Shanghai 201299,China)

机构地区：[1]上海市浦东新区人民检察院张江地区检察院,上海201299

出　　处：《上海公安学院学报》2020年第5期50-54,共5页Journal of Shanghai Police College

摘　　要：同时实施暴力和取财两种行为的犯罪,可能既符合寻衅滋事罪中的“随意殴打”“强拿硬要”特征,也符合抢劫罪中的“以暴力手段劫取公私财物”。在实践中要根据案情,基于两罪不同的构成要件,着眼于行为人的主观犯意、暴力行为手段程度特征、刑法基本原则与立法精神等方面,再结合竞合理论进行个案辨析。The crime of using force and taking property may conform to the characteristics of not only"beating at will"and"extortion"but also the"robbing public and private property by violence".In practice,based on case facts and the different constitutive requirements of the two crimes,prosecutors should focus on the subjective intention of the perpetrator,such characteristics as violent behaviors and extents,the basic principles of criminal law and the spirit of legislation and so on,and then take the theory of Co-opetition for reference before analyzing the particular case.

关 键 词：抢劫罪 强拿硬要型寻衅滋事罪 认知因素 意志因素 竟合 

分 类 号：D914[政治法律—刑法学]