行政诉讼受案范围“权利义务实际影响”条款的应然范围  

Ought-to-be Scope of“Actual Impact of Rights and Obligations”Clauses of Administrative Litigation Scope

作　　者：柳砚涛[1] 原浩洋 Liu Yantao;Yuan Haoyang

机构地区：[1]山东大学法学院

出　　处：《人权研究（辑刊）》2021年第1期385-413,522,523,共31页Journal of Human Rights

基　　金：山东省2017年社科规划重点项目“行政审判参照惯例问题研究”(项目编号:17BFXJ03)的阶段性成果。

摘　　要：为穷尽“权利义务实际影响”条款应然范围,必须将“权利义务实际影响”置于“行政过程+权利义务实际影响”而非“行政行为+权利义务实际影响”模式,彻底消除一些理论观点和司法个案强加于条款之上的最终性、实体性、确定性、已然性、直接性、显明性等“法外要求”,并在其与受案范围、原告主体资格之间保持应然一致性。In order to possibly cover the entire ought-to-be scope of the“Actual Impact of Rights and Obligations”clauses,the mode of combination of the "Administrative Procedure and the Actual Impact of Rights and Obligations",rather than the combination of"Administrative Behavior and the Actual Impact of Rights and Obligations",shall be applied to"the Actual Impact of Rights and Obligations".Moreover,the requirements beyond the laws as finality,substantiality,determinacy,factuality,substantivity and evidence shall be e-liminated from the aforementioned clauses by certain theoretical perspectives and judicial cases.An ought-to-be consistency shall be kept among the Actual Impact of Rights and Obligations,the scope of administrative litigation and the right of plaintiff as principal.

关 键 词：权利义务实际影响 受案范围 原告资格标准 应然范围 

分 类 号：D925.3[政治法律—诉讼法学]