《中国小儿急救医学》栏目设置综合评价研究  

Comprehensive evaluation of columns in Chinese Pediatric Emergency Medicine

作　　者：林强[1] 李巍[1] 徐昕[2] 张薇[1] 林楠[1] 刘春峰[1] Lin Qiang;Li Wei;Xu Xin;Zhang Wei;Lin Nan;Liu Chunfeng(Editorial Department of Chinese Pediatric Emergency Medicine,Shengjing Hospital of China Medical University,Shenyang 110004,China;Department of Clinical Epidemiology,Shengjing Hospital of China Medical University,Shenyang 110004,China)

机构地区：[1]中国医科大学附属盛京医院《中国小儿急救医学》编辑部,沈阳110004 [2]中国医科大学附属盛京医院临床流行病学教研室,沈阳110004

出　　处：《中国小儿急救医学》2021年第8期707-711,共5页Chinese Pediatric Emergency Medicine

摘　　要：目的:从传播效果和引证效果两方面对《中国小儿急救医学》栏目进行综合评价,分析各栏目设置的优势与不足,为期刊组稿提供循证依据,指导栏目选题策划,合理安排栏目版面。方法:统计《中国小儿急救医学》2016至2018年栏目的传播指标(官网浏览频次、官网下载频次、万方下载频次)和引证指标(被引频次、零被引率、高被引率、高被引频次比),分析6个常设栏目之间各评价指标是否具有统计学差异。结果:传播指标方面:排名前20位的栏目传播指标中评论类和指导类栏目占有极高的比重;评论类和指导类栏目的传播指标频次明显高于其他栏目,差异均有统计学意义;论著和临床应用研究栏目间差异无统计学意义。引证指标方面:论著栏目的被引频次和高被引率最高,零被引率最低,专家笔谈、临床应用研究、综述及指南·共识·解读4个栏目间差异无统计学意义;指南·共识·解读栏目的高被引频次比最高,论著栏目次之,两个栏目均要明显高于专家笔谈栏目;在排名前20位被引频次最高的论文分布中,论著类栏目占比65%。结论:评论类栏目(专家笔谈)和指导类栏目(指南·共识·解读)是影响期刊传播效果的关键;论著类栏目(论著)和指导类栏目(指南·共识·解读)是影响期刊引证效果的关键;评价指标绝对值的大小并不能科学评价期刊学术质量的高低。Objective This paper makes a comprehensive evaluation on the columns of Chinese Pediatric Emergency Medicine from communication effect and citation effect,and analyzes the advantages and disadvantages of each column setting,so as to provide evidence-based basis for journal soliciting contributions,and guide column selection planning.Methods The communication index(website browsing frequency,website download frequency,Wanfang download frequency)and citation index(citation frequency,zero citation rate,high citation rate,high citation rate ratio)of columns in Chinese Pediatric Emergency Medicine from 2016 to 2018 were counted,and whether there were statistical differences among the evaluation indexes of columns was analyzed.Results In terms of communication index:among the top 20 column communication indicators,comments and guidance columns account for a very high proportion;The communication index of comment column and guidance column was significantly higher than that of other columns,and the differences were statistically significant;There was no significant difference between Article column and Clinical application research column.In terms of citation index:the citation frequency and high citation rate of the Article column are the highest,while the zero citation rate is the lowest,and there was no significant difference among the four columns of Expert forum,Clinical application research,Review and Guideline·consensus·interpretation;The high citation rate ratio of the Guideline·consensus·interpretation column is the highest,followed by the Article column,and the two columns are significantly higher than the Expert forum column;Among the top 20 papers with the highest citation frequency,the column of treatise accounts for 65%.Conclusion Expert forum column and Guidelin·consensus·interpretation column are the key to influence the communication effect of journals.Article column and Guidelin·consensus·interpretation column are the key to influence the citation effect of journals.The absolute value of evalua

关 键 词：栏目 评论类栏目 指导类栏目 论著类栏目 传播指标 引证指标 

分 类 号：G237.5[文化科学] R-5[医药卫生]