现当代古体诗词应否入史之论争的核心问题思考  

Reflections on the Core Issues of the Debate on Whether Modern and Contemporary Ancient Poetry Should Enter History

作　　者：谭光辉 王辉 TAN Guanghui;WANG Hui(Bashu Culture Research Center,School of Literature,Sichuan Normal University,Chengdu,Sichuan 610068)

机构地区：[1]四川师范大学巴蜀文化研究中心、四川师范大学文学院,四川成都610068

出　　处：《中国文学研究》2023年第3期29-36,共8页Research of Chinese Literature

基　　金：四川师范大学校级专项项目“研究阐释党的十九届五中全会精神”(19J5Z2020-19)。

摘　　要：文学史是一个具有某种逻辑链的叙述文本。现当代古体诗词未能进入现当代文学史的根本原因,是其未能进入现当代文学史叙述的三个主要逻辑链:革命历史逻辑链、现代性逻辑链和文学自身逻辑链。现当代文学史收录古体诗词不符合“故事链逻辑自洽”的文学史叙述原则。造成这一现状的原因有三个方面:一是古体诗词创作思想创新不足,未能形成具有可叙述性的史学品质;二是现当代文学史家视野不够宽广,为文学史观所局限;三是古代文学史家思想不够开放,未能将研究视野拓展至当下。解决此问题的办法是文学研究内部各学科、各群体加强交流,增进理解,取长补短,消除偏见,与时俱进,打破学科壁垒,重塑文学研究总体格局。Literary history is a narrative text with a certain logical chain.The fundamental reason why modern and contemporary ancient poems fail to enter the history of modern and contemporary literature is that they fail to enter the three main logical chains of modern and contemporary literary history narration:the logical chain of revolutionary history,the logical chain of modernity and the logical chain of literature itself.The collection of ancient poems in the history of modern and contemporary literature does not conform to the narrative principle of“logical self-consistency of story chain”.There are three reasons for this situation.One is the lack of innovation in the creation of ancient poetry,which failed to form a narrative historical quality;second,the horizon of modern and contemporary literary historians is not broad enough,which is limited by the concept of literary history;third,ancient literary historians are not open enough to expand their research horizons to the present.The way to solve this problem is to strengthen the communication among various disciplines and groups in literary research,enhance understanding,learn from each other,eliminate prejudice,keep pace with the times,break discipline barriers,and reshape the overall pattern of literary research.

关 键 词：古体诗词 现当代文学史 入史品质 文学史观 历史逻辑链 

分 类 号：I026[文学—文学理论]