美德认识论与中国哲学之间的首次系统性对话——评黄勇编《当索萨遭遇中国哲学:跨文化视野下的美德认识论》  

The First Systematic Dialogue Between Virtue Epistemology and Chinese Philosophy——Review of Yong Huang's Ernest Sosa Encountering Chinese Philosophy: A Cross-Cultural Approach to Virtue Epistemology

作　　者：胡湘农 Hu Xiangnong

机构地区：[1]复旦大学哲学学院,上海200433

出　　处：《国际儒学（中英文）》2023年第4期160-168,185,186,共11页International Studies on Confucianism

摘　　要：在黄勇教授主编的《当索萨遭遇中国哲学:跨文化视野下的美德认识论》一书中,当代美德认识论学说的奠基者欧内斯特·索萨和从事中国哲学及中西比较哲学研究的共十一位学者之间围绕着与美德认识论相关的话题展开了深入讨论。这种跨文化、跨哲学传统的讨论一方面为以索萨为代表的西方认识论学者提供了了解和借鉴中国哲学的机会,另一方面也促使了中国哲学通过自我反思来建构和发展属于自身传统的美德认识论。由于中西方哲学在美德认识论的话题上一直缺乏富有成效且较为系统的对话,本书的出现填补了这一学术上的空白,进而也为两大哲学传统未来在相关领域更进一步的交流奠定了基础。In the book entitled Ernest Sosa Encountering Chinese Philosophy: A Cross-Cultural Approach to Virtue Epistemology edited by Yong Huang,Ernest Sosa,the founder of contemporary virtue epistemology,had thorough discussions with eleven scholars working on Chinese philosophy and ChineseWestern comparative philosophy on various topics related to virtue epistemology. These cross-cultural discussions provide Western epistemologists such as Sosa the chance to approach and seek resources from Chinese philosophy on the one hand while pressing Chinese philosophy to develop its own theories of virtue epistemology through self-examination on the other. Since Chinese and Western philosophy has not formed any effective and systematic dialogue on virtue epistemology,the book fills this academic gap and also lays the foundation for future Chinese-Western interchange of virtue epistemological insights.

关 键 词：美德认识论 索萨 黄勇 中国哲学 比较哲学 

分 类 号：B82-054.9[哲学宗教—伦理学]