KK论辩:一个人能够知道自己知道吗?  

KK Argumentation:Could One Know His Own Knowledge

作　　者：姚磊 YAO Lei(Biquan Academy,Xiangtan University,Xiangtan,Hunan 411105)

机构地区：[1]湘潭大学碧泉书院,湖南湘潭411105

出　　处：《绵阳师范学院学报》2024年第7期8-13,41,共7页Journal of Mianyang Teachers＇ College

基　　金：湖南省教育厅重点项目“动态认知逻辑视域下的协议信息研究”(21A0075)。

摘　　要：如果一个人拥有某种知识,那么他能清醒地认识到他拥有这种知识吗?辛迪卡的KK原则肯定了理性主体对认识自身所知的认知能力,威廉姆森用容错边际原则对此表示反对。分别从支持和反对KK原则的两派出发,以辛迪卡和威廉姆森为代表,详细考察二者的论述过程及其蕴含的哲学立场,最后从公共知识的实用主义角度对KK原则进行辩护。对KK原则的研究有利于揭示知识的定义以及公共知识等概念的深刻内涵。Can a person be aware of possessing a certain knowledge if he indeed possess it?Hintikka's KK principle affirms the cognitive capacity of rational agents to know their own knowledge,while Williamson opposes it with his margin for error principle.From the perspectives of proponents and opponents of the KK principle,repre⁃sented by Hintikka and Williamson respectively,this paper meticulously examines their process of argumentation and their philosophical positions embedded there.Finally,it defends the KK principle from the standpoint of prag⁃matism of public knowledge.Researches on the KK principle are conducive to revealing the definition of knowl⁃edge and the profound connotation of such a definition as public knowledge,etc.

关 键 词：KK原则 辛迪卡 威廉姆森 容错边际原则 公共知识 

分 类 号：B815[哲学宗教—逻辑学]